Expired listings
Homeowners whose listing came off the MLS without selling, usually called in the first days after it expires. Check the Do Not Call Registry first.
Aim for: A visit to the house with a plan for what you'd change, or a date to talk again.
Opener 1 · Direct
The straight question
“Hi, is this First name? It's My first name with [your brokerage]. I saw your home on [street] came off the market. Are you still planning to sell?”
Why: One question they can answer in a word. Within five seconds you know whether this is a real conversation.
“Got it. I'm not calling to criticize the last agent. I'd like to understand what happened, because the reason a house didn't sell usually decides what to do next.”
Why: They've had a frustrating few months. Saying what you won't do lowers their guard, and the second sentence makes the call about their house.
“Do you have three minutes now, or is later today better?”
Why: Two choices, both of them yes. Asking permission respects that you called out of the blue.
Opener 2 · Consultative
The what-happened opener
“Hi First name, this is My first name, a local agent with [your brokerage]. You've probably had a few calls like this already, so I'll be quick.”
Why: Expired sellers often hear from many agents in the first days. Saying so honestly sets you apart from callers who pretend otherwise.
“When your home was listed, what do you think kept it from selling: the price, the showings, or the timing?”
Why: Three choices make it easy to answer, and the answer is the most useful thing you'll learn on the call.
“That's helpful. If you listed again, what would you want done differently?”
Why: They describe the agent they want, which tells you exactly what to offer.
Opener 3 · Friendly
The second opinion
“Hi First name, it's My first name with [your brokerage]. I'm sorry your home on [street] didn't sell. That's a frustrating few months.”
Why: Acknowledging the disappointment first is human, and it's the opposite of the pitch they're expecting.
“I'm not asking you to list with me today. Would a free second opinion on what happened be useful, even if you take a break from selling?”
Why: A small, no-commitment offer is easy to accept and gives you a reason to see the house.
Questions to ask
“If it had sold, where were you planning to move?”
Why: The move behind the sale is the real motivation, and it tells you how much time pressure they have.
“How many showings did you get, and what feedback came back?”
Why: Few showings points to price or marketing. Lots of showings and no offers usually points to price or condition.
“What price would you need to make the move work?”
Why: It separates the number they hope for from the number they need, and tells you whether relisting makes sense.
“Is anyone else part of the decision?”
Why: A co-owner who isn't at the meeting is a common reason a listing appointment ends with “we'll think about it.”
The ask
“I'd like to see the house and bring a plan for what I'd change, with recent sales nearby. Would [day] at [time] or [day] at [time] work better?”
Why: A specific plan is the reason to meet, and two times turn “maybe” into a calendar entry.
